What is coalition loyalty?

Coalition schemes are familiar to customers and almost entirely closed to independents: they require scale, a negotiated commercial agreement, and acceptance that the data belongs to the operator. For a single shop the more important point is how to compete with one. A coalition's weakness is that its rewards accumulate slowly towards something abstract, spread across dozens of retailers. An independent's card gives a specific item, at this business, reachable in weeks. Competing on the coalition's own terms, a fractional-percentage points return, abandons the one advantage an independent has.

Can a small business join a coalition scheme?

Rarely, and the terms are the reason rather than the technology. These schemes are built around large retail chains, and participation involves a commercial agreement and fees that assume scale an independent does not have.

The harder objection is ownership. In a coalition the operator holds the customer relationship and the data, which means a business is renting access to its own customers.

How does an independent compete with a coalition card?

By being specific where the coalition is diffuse: a named reward, at this shop, reachable within weeks rather than years. That is the one dimension where a national scheme cannot match a single business.

It also helps to accept that customers will hold both. A coalition card and a shop's own card are not competing for the same slot in a wallet, and asking a customer to choose is a contest there is no need to enter.

Is a coalition card worth more to the customer?

It is worth more in breadth and much less in immediacy, and immediacy is what changes behaviour. Points spread across dozens of retailers towards a distant reward produce far weaker motivation than a card two stamps from a free coffee.

This is the goal-gradient effect working against the coalition: the closer a visible finish line, the harder people pursue it, and a coalition scheme rarely has a finish line in view.

See also

• First-party data: First-party data is information a business collects directly from its own customers, such as a phone number given at the counter, and in a loyalty programme it is the asset the programme produces.
• Goal-gradient effect: The goal-gradient effect is the observed tendency for people to accelerate their effort as they get closer to a reward, which is the psychological mechanism a stamp card relies on.
• Points programme: A points programme awards points in proportion to how much a customer spends (typically one point per unit of currency) and unlocks a reward once a threshold is reached.
• Digital loyalty card: A digital loyalty card is a loyalty card held on a customer's phone rather than on paper, most commonly as a card in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet, which records progress towards a reward and updates itself when the business adds to it.

Further reading

Back to loyalty and wallet glossary